Eye Allergies vs. Conjunctivitis in Children: What Parents Should Know

SpecSMART Eye Clinic Ikoyi Optometrist performing an Eye vision test on a boy

 

By Dr. Adaeze Nwoko [OD]

Understanding the Difference Matters

Red, itchy eyes in children are common—but not all red eyes are the same. Two of the most frequent causes are eye allergies and conjunctivitis (commonly known as pink eye). Although their symptoms may overlap, these conditions have different causes and require different treatments. At SpecSMART Eye Clinic Ikoyi, our pediatric optometrists help parents distinguish between the two so children receive timely and appropriate care.

What Are Eye Allergies?

Eye allergies, or allergic conjunctivitis, happen when a child’s immune system overreacts to allergens like pollen, dust, mold, or pet dander. They are typically seasonal and not contagious.

Common symptoms of eye allergies include:

 - Itchy, watery eyes
- Redness and swelling
- Light sensitivity
- Frequent eye rubbing
- Both eyes usually affected

    What Is Conjunctivitis (Pink Eye)?

    Conjunctivitis is inflammation of the conjunctiva—the transparent membrane covering the white of the eye and inner eyelid. It can be caused by bacterial or viral infections, allergens, or chemical irritants.

    Common symptoms of conjunctivitis include:

      - Redness and irritation
     - Watery or mucous discharge
     - Itching or burning sensation
     - Crusting around the eyelids
     - Starts in one eye and may spread to the other
     - Contagious if caused by a virus or bacteria

     

    Visual comparison of healthy eye vs viral, bacterial, and allergic conjunctivitis
    Fig. 1: Different Appearances of Conjunctivitis (Adam Debrowski, 2020).

    Eye Allergies vs. Conjunctivitis: Key Differences


    Feature Eye Allergies Conjunctivitis (Pink Eye)
    Description Allergic reaction in the eyes Inflammation of the conjunctiva
    Causes Allergens (pollen, dust, dander) Viruses, bacteria, irritants
    Symptoms Itching, tearing, swelling, redness Redness, itching, tearing, discharge
    Discharge Clear, watery Watery, thick yellow/green
    Eyes affected Usually both Often starts in one, spreads to both
    Contagious? No Yes (if viral or bacterial)
    Time of the year Seasonal Year Round
    Treatment Antihistamines, Avoidance Antibiotics, lubricants, cleansing


    Treatment Options

    For Eye Allergies:

      - Use over-the-counter or prescription antihistamine drops
     - Apply cold compresses to reduce swelling
     - Avoid exposure to known allergens
     - Encourage children not to rub their eyes

    For Conjunctivitis:

     - Viral: Usually resolves in 4–7 days with supportive care
    - Bacterial: Requires antibiotic eye drops or ointment
    - Allergic: Similar to standard eye allergy treatment
    - Irritant-based: Immediate rinsing and warm compress


    Prevention Tips

     - Encourage frequent handwashing
    - Avoid touching or rubbing the eyes
    - Do not share towels, pillows, or eye cosmetics
    - Use clean tissues or disposable wipes for eye discharge
    - Wear eye protection in dusty or allergen-heavy environments

    References

    Adam, D. (2020). Types of Conjunctivitis: Allergic, Bacterial and Viral. Retrieved from https://www.allaboutvision.com/conditions/conjunctivitis-types.htm

     

    Frequently Asked Questions

    1. Can my child go to school with pink eye?

    If the conjunctivitis is caused by a virus or bacteria, it’s best to keep your child home until they are no longer contagious. Your optometrist will advise based on the type of infection.

    2. How can I tell if it’s an allergy or an infection?

    Eye allergies usually affect both eyes and cause clear, watery discharge with intense itching. Infections often start in one eye and produce thicker discharge. A clinical exam is the most reliable way to differentiate.

    3. When should I see an eye doctor?

    If symptoms persist beyond a few days, worsen, or involve pain, light sensitivity, or changes in vision, visit an eye specialist promptly. At SpecSMART Eye Clinic Ikoyi, we offer child-friendly, advanced diagnostics to accurately assess and treat both conditions.

    Your Child’s Vision Deserves Expert Care

    Red or itchy eyes in children shouldn’t be ignored. Whether it's allergies or an infection, accurate diagnosis and prompt treatment are key to preventing discomfort and complications. Book a pediatric eye exam at SpecSMART Eye Clinic Ikoyi to get clarity and peace of mind.

    📍Learn More: 

    Our 5 Step Eye Test Process Explained in  more detail

    Visit our Website

     

     📍 Contact SpecSMART Eye Clinic Ikoyi

    📍 SpecSMART Eye Clinic Ikoyi
          Ikoyi Plaza, Junction of Awolowo Road and Keffi Street, Ikoyi, Lagos
    📞 Tel: 0701 820 7486
    🌐 Website: https://specsmart.ng/pages/ikoyi-eye-clinic